If you thought Noah and Nick had already weathered every storm, Your Fault: London proves that miscommunication and jealousy can still tear a couple apart. The second film in the trilogy finds the young lovers—played by Asha Banks and Matthew Broome—spiraling as Noah dives into Oxford life and Nick gets consumed by work. Small cracks become gaping chasms, and by the end, a brutal cliffhanger leaves fans reeling. But as Banks and Broome reveal in an exclusive interview, there’s a light at the end of the tunnel—and it’s already been filmed.
Facing the Fan Frenzy
Stepping into a beloved franchise is never easy, especially when fans have strong attachments to previous portrayals. Banks admits the pressure was real: “People responded well to the first one, and that almost made it more nerve-wracking coming back. We wanted to do the second book and movie as much justice as the first.” Broome adds that they came in as “strangers” hoping to win over the fan base. “It’s nice to be putting something out there for people who really want to receive it,” he says. But with this installment’s darker turns, the duo knows some viewers might get upset. Banks jokes, “Stay on our side, please! Stay with us!”
The Race Scene: Bickering in a Confined Space
One of the film’s most intense sequences has Noah and Nick trapped in a car during a high-stakes race, arguing while trying to win. Banks calls it “the hardest one of the second movie.” She explains, “We had to do our racing, but together in a scene where we’re bickering and it’s so fast-paced. It feels so silly being in a car surrounded by screens, and we’re fighting and pretending to race.” Broome chimes in, “With the crew shaking the car and spraying water on it.” Despite the absurdity, the final product looks thrilling—thanks to VFX and the crew’s efforts. “We were thinking too much about ourselves,” Banks laughs.
Dressing Up as a Spice Girl
Banks also got to live out a childhood fantasy when her character dressed as Posh Spice for a party. “That was the first thing I did in my fitting,” she recalls. “They whipped out a wig, a bob, and tried to fit my amount of hair in a wig cap, which was quite difficult. It was so much fun.” She even had to stop herself from asking to keep the costume.
The Cliffhanger and What Comes Next
The film ends with a devastating betrayal that leaves Noah and Nick’s future uncertain. But fans can rest easy: the third film, Our Fault: London, is already shot and promises resolution. “There’s a light at the end of the tunnel,” Banks teases. Broome adds that the story’s evolution will satisfy those who’ve stuck with the couple through all the chaos. For now, the stars are just grateful for the support—and bracing for the emotional fallout of that cliffhanger.
For more on the twists and turns of this trilogy, check out our interview with the cast of Every Year After, who also faced a shocking season finale.
