The thriller genre has given us some of cinema's most gripping and unforgettable experiences. But for every Se7en or Gone Girl, there's a dud that makes you question why you ever pressed play. These are the thrillers that are so poorly conceived, so badly executed, and so utterly devoid of tension that they're practically unwatchable.
From misguided sequels to tone-deaf exploitation, these films fail on nearly every level. They're not just bad; they're the kind of movies that make you want to demand your time back. So, grab your remote and prepare to hit skip—these are the most unwatchable thrillers since 2000, ranked.
5. Basic Instinct 2 (2006)
Sharon Stone returns as the manipulative Catherine Trammell in this baffling sequel that squanders any goodwill the original might have earned. Set in London, Trammell becomes the focus of a police investigation after her latest lover dies in a car crash. A court-appointed psychiatrist, played by David Morrissey, is tasked with evaluating her and inevitably falls into her web of seduction and danger.
The original Basic Instinct was a stylish, if trashy, erotic thriller that benefited from Stone's iconic performance. This sequel, however, is a mess. The plot is laughably weak, the dialogue is cringe-worthy, and both Stone and Morrissey deliver performances that are either wooden or over-the-top. It's a film that fails to be thrilling, erotic, or even entertainingly bad—it's just dull.
4. Killing Me Softly (2002)
Heather Graham and Joseph Fiennes star in this erotic thriller that goes nowhere slowly. Graham plays Alice, an American who leaves her boyfriend for a mysterious mountain climber named Adam (Fiennes). After a whirlwind romance and quick marriage, Alice begins to suspect Adam has a dark past, including the suspicious deaths of his previous lovers.
Directed by Chen Kaige, this is the kind of film that makes you wonder how it ever got made. The plot is nonsensical, the pacing is glacial, and the so-called twists are eye-rollingly predictable. Even the usually talented Graham and Fiennes can't save this mess. It's a thriller that's neither thrilling nor sexy—just boring and frustrating.
3. Gotti (2018)
John Travolta dons heavy prosthetics to play the infamous mob boss John Gotti in this biopic that's more laughable than menacing. The film tries to cover decades of Gotti's life, from his rise to power in the Gambino crime family to his legal battles and strained relationships with his wife and son.
Director Kevin Connolly seems completely out of his depth, delivering a film that's poorly paced and tonally all over the place. Travolta's performance is hammy, and the script tries to glorify a criminal in a way that's both problematic and unintentionally funny. It's a movie that's so bad it's almost fascinating, but not in a good way.
2. The Haunting of Sharon Tate (2019)
This is not just a bad movie; it's an offensive one. Starring Hilary Duff as Sharon Tate, the film imagines the days leading up to her murder by the Manson Family as a series of hallucinations and premonitions. It's a tasteless exploitation of a real-life tragedy that serves no purpose other than to shock.
The acting is terrible, the script is ridiculous, and the direction is clumsy. The twist ending is the final nail in the coffin, making the whole thing feel like a cheap horror movie rather than a respectful tribute. It's a film that should never have been made, and watching it feels like a betrayal of Tate's memory.
1. The Last Days of American Crime (2020)
Topping our list is Netflix's The Last Days of American Crime, a film that's as boring as it is nonsensical. Set in a near-future where the government is about to activate a signal that prevents people from committing crimes, a group of criminals races to pull off one final heist. The cast includes Édgar Ramírez, but even he can't save this mess.
The film is overlong, poorly written, and features action sequences that are more confusing than exciting. It tries to be a gritty crime thriller but ends up being a tedious slog. It's the kind of movie that makes you check your watch every five minutes, and by the end, you'll wonder why you didn't just watch something else. For more on why some thrillers nail their openings, check out this analysis.
These films are a reminder that not all thrillers are created equal. While some keep you on the edge of your seat, these will have you reaching for the remote. If you're looking for something better, consider these gripping detective shows or these quick thriller reads. And if you're a fan of the genre, you might also enjoy these memorable crime villains.
