Apple TV+'s Widows Bay has become a cult sensation, blending spine-tingling horror with sharp, dry humor in a way that feels both fresh and nostalgic. Created by Katie Dippold, the series follows Mayor Tom Loftis (Matthew Rhys) as he tries to turn a remote New England island into a tourist hotspot, only to awaken a centuries-old curse. With eccentric characters, over-the-top situations, and a Stephen King-inspired logo, it's a show that demands a rewatch to catch every Easter egg. But while you wait for Season 2, here are some must-watch shows that capture a similar vibe.
Dark Comedy Mysteries
'Deadloch' (2023–Present)
This Australian sleeper hit flips the Nordic Noir genre on its head. Set in a sleepy Tasmanian town, two mismatched detectives—tightly wound local Dulie Collins (Kate Box) and brash outsider Eddie Redcliffe (Madelleine Sami)—must team up to catch a serial killer. The show subverts cop tropes with biting humor, rapid-fire one-liners, and a scathing social commentary that puts queer, Indigenous, and female characters at the center. It's a masterful mix of comedy and mystery, much like Widows Bay.
Supernatural Horror with Heart
'From' (2022–Present)
If you love the mystery-box tension of Widows Bay, From is a perfect follow-up. Created by John Griffin, this sci-fi horror series traps residents in a small town terrorized by nocturnal, humanoid monsters. Led by Harold Perrineau's Boyd Stevens, the community must survive using protective talismans. The show balances suspenseful lore with psychological drama, keeping you hooked as new mysteries unfold. It's a nightmare you can't escape—and that's a good thing.
Ghostly Comedies
'Ghosts' (2021–Present)
For a lighter take on the supernatural, CBS's Ghosts follows a young couple who inherit a country estate and discover they can see the quirky ghosts who haunt it. With a blend of heart and humor, the show explores co-existence between the living and the dead. It's a celebration of diversity and a reminder that not all spirits are scary—some just need a good laugh.
Other series like What We Do in the Shadows, Twin Peaks, and Gravity Falls also share Widows Bay's tone. For more binge-worthy picks, check out our list of 11 Perfect Fantasy TV Shows We Absolutely Can't Live Without or dive into Apple TV's Most-Watched Sci-Fi Series. And if you're curious about the show's creator, read about Homeland Creator Gideon Raff's New Spy Thriller.
Whether you prefer dark comedy, supernatural horror, or ghostly antics, these shows will fill the void until Widows Bay returns. Happy bingeing!
