While 2026 has been a whirlwind for Tom Holland and Zendaya, who both starred in Christopher Nolan's epic The Odyssey and the record-breaking Spider-Man: Brand New Day, another actor has quietly been making waves on streaming. Jon Bernthal, who shared the screen with the power couple in both blockbusters, is now seeing his underrated 2025 spy thriller The Amateur climb the charts on Prime Video.
As of this week, The Amateur sits comfortably in the top 10 most-streamed movies on Prime Video in the U.S. The film, which stars Oscar-winner Rami Malek as a CIA cryptographer turned vigilante, has found a new audience after a modest theatrical run. It's a different kind of revenge story—one that leans more into emotional depth than non-stop action, a refreshing change for fans of the genre.
A Stellar Cast Elevates the Thriller
Malek leads a powerhouse ensemble that includes Jon Bernthal, Rachel Brosnahan, Laurence Fishburne, Caitríona Balfe, and Michael Stuhlbarg. Each actor brings their A-game, making The Amateur a gripping watch from start to finish. The chemistry between Malek and Bernthal is particularly compelling, adding layers to a story that could have easily fallen into cliché.
Despite receiving positive reviews from critics and audiences alike, the film only grossed $96 million worldwide against a $60 million budget during its initial release. Collider's Jeff Ewing praised it as a "solid spy thriller, though one a little more emotional and a little less action-heavy than one might expect from the premise." That emotional core is likely why it's resonating with streaming audiences now.
Why It's Worth Your Time
If you're in the mood for a spy thriller that prioritizes character over explosions, The Amateur is a must-watch. It's a slow-burn that rewards patience, and Malek's performance is a reminder of his range beyond Bohemian Rhapsody and No Time to Die. For those who enjoyed recent nerve-shredding thrillers, this one fits right in.
The film's streaming success also highlights a trend of underappreciated movies finding new life on platforms like Prime Video. Just as Hugh Jackman's Van Helsing and Russell Crowe's Unabomber thriller have done recently, The Amateur is proving that a theatrical flop can become a streaming gem.
Where to Watch
The Amateur is currently streaming on Prime Video. If you're looking for more under-the-radar thrillers, check out Starz's The Rook, another forgotten spy series that blends Fringe with Jason Bourne. And for those who prefer a weekend binge, Peacock's All Her Fault is an eight-episode thriller you won't want to put down.
With Bernthal's busy year and Malek's star power, The Amateur is a testament to the enduring appeal of a well-crafted revenge story. Whether you missed it in theaters or are discovering it for the first time, it's a worthy addition to your watchlist this October.
