Taylor Sheridan has become a dominant force in television, building an empire that stretches from the Montana ranches of Yellowstone to the urban prisons of Mayor of Kingstown. As a fan who followed him from his acclaimed films to the small screen, I've experienced the full spectrum of his output—the thrilling highs and the occasional letdowns. While his work often sparks debate, there's no denying his impact. Here is my personal ranking of all 12 Taylor Sheridan TV shows, from the bottom to the very top.
The Reality Ventures & Newcomers
Starting at the lower end of the list, we find Sheridan's forays into reality television. In last place is The Road (2025–Present), a CBS reality competition he produced. While not my usual genre, the show is undeniably a passion project for Sheridan, a known country music enthusiast. It features Keith Urban and Blake Shelton mentoring unknown singers on a cross-country tour, with Sheridan himself making appearances. The production is slick and the talent is genuine, but it remains a niche entry for me.
Similarly, The Last Cowboy (2019–Present) offers a fascinating glimpse into the world of competitive horse reining. This CMT reality series is educational and well-made, showcasing the profound bond between trainers and their horses. However, its repetitive format prevents it from climbing higher in the rankings.
Then there's Marshals (2026–Present), a Yellowstone spin-off that has struggled to find its footing. Following Kayce Dutton (Luke Grimes) after a personal tragedy, the show sees him join a law enforcement team led by a Navy SEAL friend. Despite a strong cast, the shift from prestige drama to a network crime procedural with a 'case-of-the-week' structure has resulted in lukewarm reception. It feels disconnected from the gritty soul of its predecessor, though I remain hopeful for its future.
The Gritty Dramas & Steady Performers
Landing in the middle of the pack is Mayor of Kingstown (2021–Present). This Jeremy Renner-led drama about power brokers in a prison town is undeniably grim and intense. Its latest season, however, represents an all-time high for the series, with Renner's powerhouse performance and sharply raised stakes earning impressive audience scores. It's a solid, if brutally dark, entry in Sheridan's catalog.
This ranking naturally leads to discussions about Sheridan's other hits. For instance, the recent success of shows like Landman demonstrates his continued dominance in the neo-western genre he helped redefine.
The Crown Jewels of the Sheridan-Verse
Now we ascend to Sheridan's most acclaimed work. The Yellowstone universe rightly claims top spots, with the flagship series itself setting the gold standard for modern family sagas set against the American West. Its prequels, like 1923, have successfully expanded the mythology with stellar casts and epic storytelling.
Newer series like Landman and Tulsa King have also quickly cemented themselves as fan favorites. Tulsa King, with Sylvester Stallone's magnetic turn as a displaced mafia capo, showcases Sheridan's talent for crafting compelling, character-driven stories outside the ranch setting. These series exemplify why Sheridan's television work has garnered such a devoted following: they are immersive, well-acted, and packed with the unpredictable twists and moral complexities he's known for.
While some viewers may critique certain elements, the cultural footprint of shows like Yellowstone is undeniable. It's interesting to see how other veteran actors, like Kevin Costner, navigate their own projects in the evolving entertainment landscape.
From his reality TV experiments to his genre-defining dramas, Taylor Sheridan's television portfolio is remarkably diverse. This ranking is, of course, subjective—a snapshot of one fan's journey through his ever-growing world. Whether you're a die-hard Dutton devotee or a curious newcomer, there's a Sheridan show that demands to be binged. Just be prepared for the ride.
