Prime Video has become a powerhouse of original programming, with hits like Invincible and The Boys redefining the superhero genre. But before these shows took the world by storm, another series quietly set the standard for superhero satire: The Tick. Created by Ben Edlund and based on his own comics, this two-season gem is a must-watch for any fan of the genre.
The Tick follows Arthur Everest (Griffin Newman), a mild-mannered accountant who crosses paths with the boisterous, blue-clad superhero known as The Tick (Peter Serafinowicz). Together, they investigate a conspiracy involving the villainous The Terror (Jackie Earle Haley). What sets The Tick apart is its ability to balance laugh-out-loud comedy with genuine emotional stakes, making it a more complete superhero thriller than its successors.
A Satire That Cuts Deep
Unlike The Boys or Invincible, which often lean into graphic violence and cynicism, The Tick uses humor to skewer superhero tropes. Characters like the trigger-happy Overkill (a clear nod to lethal vigilantes like the Punisher) and the Superman-esque Superian (Brendan Hines) are played for laughs, but the show never loses sight of its heart. It's a rare series that can make you chuckle one moment and feel deeply moved the next.
One of the show's strongest elements is its exploration of mental health. Arthur's anxiety and trauma—stemming from witnessing his father's death during a battle with The Terror—are handled with surprising sensitivity. His journey to embrace his role as The Tick's sidekick is both empowering and relatable, proving that you don't need superpowers to be a hero. This emotional depth is something The Boys and Invincible would later explore, but The Tick did it first—and without the bloodshed.
Overshadowed but Unforgettable
Despite its critical acclaim, The Tick struggled to find an audience in a crowded market. Season 1 premiered in 2016, competing with blockbusters like Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice and Suicide Squad. Season 2 faced even stiffer competition from Avengers: Infinity War and the debut of The Boys. Sadly, the series was canceled after two seasons, leaving fans with unresolved storylines.
In a bittersweet twist, Valorie Curry, who played Arthur's sister Dot, went on to star as Firecracker in The Boys. Her role serves as a reminder of the talent that made The Tick so special. While The Boys and Invincible continue to dominate headlines, The Tick remains a hidden gem that paved the way for their success.
If you're looking for a superhero thriller that combines wit, heart, and a touch of absurdity, The Tick is the perfect binge. It's a show that deserves to be rediscovered—and one that proves Prime Video's library is richer than you think. For more underrated streaming gems, check out our list of Prime Video Shows That Demand a Binge-Watch.
