Back in 2017, NBC took a swing at filling the blood-soaked void left by HBO's True Blood with a quirky, small-town supernatural series called Midnight, Texas. Based on Charlaine Harris' book trilogy (yes, the same author who gave us Sookie Stackhouse), the show followed a psychic named Manfred Bernardo as he moved to a remote Texas town that served as a sanctuary for vampires, witches, werewolves, and other paranormal beings. Despite a devoted fanbase and a solid premise, the series was canceled after just two seasons. But in an era where streaming revivals are all the rage, Midnight, Texas deserves a second chance.
A Town Full of Secrets and Supernatural Charm
Set in the dusty, isolated town of Midnight, the series introduced viewers to a colorful cast of characters, including a vampire who ran a pawnshop, a witch who owned a bed-and-breakfast, and a fallen angel. The show balanced dark, violent conflicts with heartfelt moments and even a touch of humor. It wasn't just a True Blood clone—it carved out its own identity by focusing on found family and the struggles of outsiders trying to live peacefully in a world that fears them.
Why It Was Canceled Too Soon
Despite strong source material and a talented ensemble, Midnight, Texas struggled with mixed reviews and inconsistent ratings. Some critics felt the show tried to do too much at once, juggling multiple supernatural factions and a sprawling mystery. But fans argue that the series was just hitting its stride when NBC pulled the plug. The second season ended on a major cliffhanger, leaving viewers desperate for closure.
In a landscape where shows like Warehouse 13 are seeing renewed interest on streaming platforms, Midnight, Texas could easily find a new audience. The series is currently available on Peacock, and its cult following has only grown since its cancellation. With the right marketing and a tighter focus, a revival could finally deliver the satisfying conclusion fans have been waiting for.
A Perfect Fit for the Streaming Era
Streaming services have breathed new life into many canceled shows, from Arrested Development to Lucifer. Midnight, Texas has all the ingredients for a successful comeback: a built-in fanbase, a rich mythology, and a creator (Monica Owusu-Breen) who has proven her chops on shows like Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. and Fringe. Plus, the supernatural genre is hotter than ever, with hits like Wednesday and The Sandman dominating streaming charts.
If you're looking for a binge-worthy series that blends mystery, romance, and the paranormal, Midnight, Texas is a hidden gem worth discovering. And who knows—if enough viewers tune in, we might just see a revival that gives this underrated show the ending it deserves.
For more underrated fantasy series that deserve a second look, check out our list of 7 Underrated Fantasy Series You'll Want to Rewatch Again and Again.
