Great fantasy shows are a treat the first time around. They pull you into epic worlds, weave complex storylines, and introduce characters you can't help but root for. But the truly special ones—the ones that keep you coming back—offer something more: hidden clues, cozy escapes, or layers of humor that only get better with each viewing. Here are seven underrated fantasy series that are absolutely worth watching over and over, ranked.
7. 'Every Witch Way' (2014–2015)
This Nickelodeon gem follows Emma Alonso, a teenage girl who moves to Miami and discovers she's a witch—just like her late mother. At Iridium High, she learns she might be the Chosen One, and a coven of witches is plotting to steal her powers during the upcoming Eclipse. Despite being a kids' show, Every Witch Way boasts surprisingly deep lore, introducing multiple magical species and a compelling balance between teen drama and supernatural stakes. It's a cozy, nostalgic rewatch for anyone who loves underdog heroines and magical school settings.
6. 'What We Do in the Shadows' (2019–2024)
FX's mockumentary about a vampire household in Staten Island is a masterclass in comedic fantasy. The series follows three traditional vampires, one energy vampire, and their human familiar as they navigate mundane annoyances—like spam emails they think are cursed—while occasionally trying to conquer the world. The show's genius lies in how it expands vampire lore with absurd, hilarious twists. Every episode is packed with rewatchable gags and subtle callbacks, making it a perfect binge for fans of great sitcoms with a supernatural twist.
5. 'Galavant' (2015–2016)
This musical fairytale comedy follows the fallen knight Galavant, who must rescue Princess Isabella from the evil King Richard—all while pining for his ex, Madalena. With catchy songs, witty dialogue, and a cast that includes Timothy Omundson and Mallory Jansen, Galavant is a laugh-out-loud adventure that rewards repeat viewings. The show's clever lyrics and running jokes become even funnier the second time around, and its short run makes it an easy, joyful rewatch.
4. 'School Spirits' (2023–Present)
Maddie Nears is missing—and dead. Her ghost is trapped in her high school alongside other spirits, with no memory of how she died. With help from her ghostly friends and her living best friend Simon (the only person who can see her), Maddie investigates her own murder. What starts as a grounded teen drama quickly becomes a chilling horror series with intricate lore. Rewatching School Spirits reveals subtle clues and foreshadowing that make the twists even more satisfying. It's a must for fans of thrilling mysteries with supernatural layers.
3. 'The Good Place' (2016–2020)
Though often categorized as a comedy, The Good Place is a brilliant fantasy about the afterlife. Eleanor Shellstrop wakes up in a utopian neighborhood designed by a quirky architect, only to realize she's there by mistake. The show explores ethics, identity, and what it means to be good—all while delivering shocking plot twists. Its dense, clever writing means every rewatch uncovers new jokes and philosophical Easter eggs. For those who love page-turner fantasy, this series offers endless depth.
2. 'The OA' (2016–2019)
This Netflix series follows Prairie Johnson, a blind woman who returns home after seven years—now able to see—and gathers a group of misfits to help her prevent a tragedy. Blending sci-fi, fantasy, and metaphysical drama, The OA is a puzzle box of a show that demands rewatching. Its intricate mythology, emotional performances, and mind-bending finale leave fans debating theories long after the credits roll. It's a cult favorite that rewards patient, attentive viewers.
1. 'The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance' (2019)
A prequel to the 1982 film, this Netflix series uses stunning puppetry to tell the story of the Gelflings' rebellion against the evil Skeksis. With a star-studded voice cast and breathtaking world-building, Age of Resistance is a visual and emotional masterpiece. Every frame is packed with detail, from the intricate puppet designs to the rich lore of Thra. Rewatching reveals hidden references to the original film and deeper layers of the rebellion's tragedy. It's a must for fans of animated sci-fi and fantasy epics.
Whether you're in the mood for laughs, chills, or epic adventure, these underrated fantasy shows offer something new with every rewatch. So grab your remote, settle in, and discover why these series deserve a permanent spot in your rotation.
