The battle for Middle-earth has spilled onto Rotten Tomatoes. The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 has returned to Prime Video, and while critics are largely on board, the audience score tells a different story—one that has all the hallmarks of a coordinated review-bombing campaign.
This isn't the first time a major franchise has faced this divide. The gap between critical reception and audience sentiment has become a recurring theme in modern entertainment. From Dwayne Johnson's action flicks like Red One and Black Adam—which scored well with viewers despite mixed reviews—to the opposite scenario where fan mobs rally against a project, the pattern is all too familiar.
Review-bombing, as it's known, typically involves organized groups of disgruntled fans flooding a title with negative ratings to drag down its aggregate score. Often, these campaigns target projects that embrace inclusivity or diversity, as seen with Star Wars: The Last Jedi, The Acolyte, and HBO's The Last of Us. Now, The Rings of Power finds itself in that crosshairs.
A Costly Return to Middle-earth
Amazon's mega-budget series first premiered in 2022 with reports of a $250 million initial investment and a $1 billion commitment across five seasons. The first season boasted 150 million views, but retention reportedly dipped as the episodes rolled out. Season 2 faced similar challenges. Now, Season 3 is trying a new release strategy—dropping four episodes at once, followed by two more the next week, and the final two the week after.
On Rotten Tomatoes, the series holds an overall 83% critics' score, but the audience score sits at a meager 53%. Season 1 was hit hardest with a 38% audience score based on over 25,000 ratings. Season 3, meanwhile, has a 68% audience score—still low, but notably better than its predecessor.
Fans have been vocal in their comparisons to Peter Jackson's iconic film trilogy, questioning everything from creative choices to casting decisions. Some of that criticism is legitimate, but the sheer volume of negative ratings suggests a coordinated effort rather than organic disappointment.
For those who want to judge for themselves, The Rings of Power is streaming on Prime Video. If you're looking for other shows to binge, check out our Prime Video binge guide for recommendations. And for a deeper dive into the show's nods to Jackson's work, see our breakdown of Season 3's Nazgûl scene.
Whether the backlash will impact the show's future remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: the discourse around The Rings of Power is as heated as ever. Stay tuned for more updates as the season unfolds.
