It's been a few years since the Winchesters hung up their salt-and-burn boots, but the hunger for more Supernatural hasn't faded. Fans have been clamoring for a reunion, and it turns out one of the show's leading men has been thinking about it too. In a new exclusive interview, Jared Padalecki (Sam Winchester) shared his vision for how the beloved series could make a comeback—and it's not what you might expect.

Padalecki, who spent 15 seasons hunting monsters alongside Jensen Ackles (Dean), isn't interested in reviving the show in its original form. Instead, he's proposing a much more compact approach. "Ideally, for me, it would look something like the Gilmore Girls reboot," he said. "Like four 90-minute episodes. We'll shoot it in two months or three months." That's a far cry from the 20-plus episode seasons that defined the series' long run.

Read also
TV Shows
Scott Caan's NCIS: New York Character Loses It in Exclusive Episode 6 Clip
An exclusive NCIS: New York sneak peek shows Scott Caan's Nick Schaeffer hilariously losing it while stuck in the office with the tech team.

The actor's reasoning is practical. "I don't think any of us want to do Supernatural like we did, Seasons 1–15," he explained. "We're each at different points in our lives. We all have kids or are married. So, nine months out of the year is a lot to dedicate when you have a kid who's about to get a driver's license and a kid who's about to be a teenager."

Padalecki's pitch would bring back the show's early horror-movie vibe, when each episode felt like a standalone scare. But he's also clear about what he doesn't want: a prequel. "The one thing we cannot do is a prequel, because we look a lot older than we did 25 years ago, or 21 years ago," he noted. Instead, he envisions a story that picks up after the series finale, "Carry On," which saw both brothers die and reunite in Heaven.

"Spoiler alert for those who haven't seen it yet, but Sam and Dean pass away, and I don't know exactly where I would want it to go, but in my head, Sam and Dean wake up, and they're on Earth," Padalecki revealed. "They don't know why they're back on Earth. They don't know how they got there, and there's something they have to figure out and take care of."

That mystery could involve Jack (Alexander Calvert) bringing them back for a purpose, or some other supernatural force at play. The possibilities are endless, and Padalecki's idea has a certain appeal—it strips away the mythology-heavy arcs and gets back to the core of what made the show great: two brothers, a car, and a job to do.

The actor's comments come as fans have been buzzing about the Supernatural universe expanding. The spin-off The Winchesters explored the brothers' parents, and the recent The Boys finale brought Padalecki, Ackles, and Misha Collins together again, reigniting hopes for a proper reunion. While nothing is official, Padalecki's pitch is a tantalizing glimpse of what could be.

For now, fans can catch Padalecki in his upcoming Netflix project, Guarding Stars, and revisit the original series on streaming. And if you're in the mood for more supernatural thrills, check out Hulu's Extraordinary, a perfect binge for The Boys fans. But for those holding out hope for the Winchesters' return, Padalecki's words are a promising sign that the story isn't over yet.