In a surprising twist for DC Studios, the low-budget horror spin-off Clayface has officially surpassed Supergirl at the global box office—even after being dropped from more than 1,200 theaters. The milestone comes as the studio undergoes a major leadership shake-up, with co-CEOs James Gunn and Peter Safran departing amid questions about the franchise's direction.

Supergirl, directed by Craig Gillespie and starring Milly Alcock, was expected to be a cornerstone of the new DC Universe. Instead, it became one of 2026's biggest misfires, earning just $126 million worldwide against a budget north of $180 million. Domestically, it managed only $72 million, and critics were lukewarm, giving it a 52% score on Rotten Tomatoes.

Read also
Movies
Ramayana Epic Loses 500 Theaters but Still Rules Global Box Office
Ramayana: Rise of a Legend holds strong globally, crossing $150M, even as its domestic theater count drops by nearly 500.

Meanwhile, Clayface—a standalone body horror film directed by James Watkins—has been a critical darling. It holds a "Certified Fresh" 78% critics' score and an impressive 94% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. Produced for a reported $40 million, it has already grossed $63 million domestically and is now just $5 million shy of matching Supergirl's worldwide total. It has already beaten Supergirl internationally.

The film's theatrical run has been unusual: it opened in 3,468 locations but has since been reduced to 2,284—a loss of over 1,200 theaters. Yet its momentum remains strong, and it will hit PVOD on December 8. The contrast between the two films highlights a broader shift in DC's strategy, as the studio grapples with whether to prioritize risky, standalone stories or rely on marquee heroes to build toward a Justice League event.

For more on how DC's new leadership is approaching projects like Clayface and Lanterns, check out the challenges facing DC's new bosses. And for a deeper look at Clayface's theatrical decline, see how the horror flick lost 1,000 theaters.

Starring Tom Rhys Harries, Naomi Ackie, and Max Minghella, Clayface has carved out a unique identity in the DCU, blending body horror with a revenge thriller narrative. Its success—despite a shrinking theater count—suggests that audiences are hungry for something different from the usual superhero fare. Whether that translates into future DC projects remains to be seen, but for now, Clayface is the little engine that could.