Jared Padalecki is no stranger to being the object of affection. From his early days as Dean Forester, the first boyfriend of Rory Gilmore on Gilmore Girls, to his long run as Sam Winchester on Supernatural, he's spent decades winning over audiences. But in his new Netflix rom-com, Guarding Stars, being everyone's crush is literally the job.

Based on Katherine Center's best-selling novel The Bodyguard, the film casts Padalecki as Jack Stapleton, a movie star who falls for his bodyguard, played by Gossip Girl alum Leighton Meester. It's a festive treat that marks his return to the genre after years of hunting monsters and chasing criminals on Walker. And while it might seem like a natural fit, Padalecki admits it took some effort to get back into the romantic leading man mindset.

Read also
Streaming
Mark Wahlberg's Crime Thriller 'By Any Means' Hits Paramount+ on December 3
Mark Wahlberg's crime thriller 'By Any Means' hits Paramount+ on December 3. The film, co-starring Yahya Abdul-Mateen II, is based on a true story.

"To try and refresh that muscle, so to speak, was actually more difficult than I thought it would be," he says with a laugh, reflecting on the challenge of stepping back into a genre he hadn't visited since the underrated New York Minute.

Finding the Charm

Padalecki credits his co-star for making the transition easier. "She has a ridiculously awesome sense of humor," he says of Meester. "She's obviously a very talented actress, and she can do it all." The two seasoned actors, both with over two decades in the industry, found a natural rhythm on set, comparing their dynamic to a game of tennis where you're constantly trying new shots.

Director Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum and producer Gina Matthews encouraged that playful approach, giving the cast room to improvise and experiment. Padalecki reveals that the film's rodeo scene alone took two days to shoot, allowing the actors to really settle into their characters and the moment.

Lessons from the Past

Padalecki also reflects on how his approach to romance has evolved. In the early 2000s, he felt pressure to embody the brooding, mysterious archetype. "I was more concerned about the look of it," he admits. "Everything was like the brooding guy who's in a corner, and like, 'Just don't talk to me. I'm just so pensive,' and I kind of fell prey to that."

His agents would often remind him to tone down his naturally happy-go-lucky demeanor. "Because I'm a pretty happy-go-lucky guy, they'd be like, 'Hey, just tone it down a little bit and be mysterious.' And I'm like, 'Okay, okay. I need to eat, so I'd like to book this role.'"

Now, he's embracing a different kind of leading man, one inspired by the likes of George Clooney, Brad Pitt, Matthew McConaughey, and Hugh Grant. What draws him to these actors is their humor. "You want to be around people who laugh a lot, even in a shitty situation," he says. "That frequency is really inviting to people."

It's that warmth and wit that makes Jack Stapleton so endearing, and it's a reminder of why audiences have been falling for Padalecki for years. Whether he's revisiting his Gilmore Girls days or pitching a Supernatural revival, he brings a charm that's impossible to hide.

For fans eager to see him back in a romantic lead, Guarding Stars is a delightful holiday treat. And with the November Netflix premiere already generating buzz, it's clear that Padalecki's star power is as strong as ever.