There are only a handful of films in cinema history that share the exact same title, and The Mummy is one of them. With four distinct movies all bearing that name—spanning from the 1932 original to the 2017 Tom Cruise-led disaster—it's time to unwrap the bandages and see which one truly stands out. While none of these films are absolute masterpieces, three have something to offer, and one is just plain terrible. No prizes for guessing which.
4. The Mummy (2017)
The 2017 version is the clear bottom-dweller. This was supposed to launch Universal's Dark Universe—a cinematic universe that died before it even began. Tom Cruise stars as a soldier who accidentally awakens an ancient Egyptian princess, but the film is a messy blend of action, horror, and comedy that never quite works. The modern-day setting isn't the problem; it's the awkward pacing, the desperate franchise-building, and the sheer lack of fun. Cruise gives a forgettable performance, but no actor could salvage this script. The failure of the Dark Universe is a fascinating case study in hubris, but actually watching the movie is a chore. It's no wonder the 2026 reboot had to be called Lee Cronin's The Mummy to avoid confusion.
3. The Mummy (1959)
Hammer Film Productions brought their signature gothic style to the mummy mythos in 1959, starring Christopher Lee as the titular monster and Peter Cushing as the hero. Lee's performance is limited by the heavy makeup, but he conveys menace through his eyes and body language. The film's biggest flaw is its pacing: the extended flashback to Ancient Egypt drags, and a key female character is introduced too late in the story. Still, the atmospheric sets and the chemistry between Cushing and Lee give it a certain charm. It's a solid entry for fans of classic horror, but it doesn't quite reach the heights of Hammer's best work, like their 1958 Dracula.
2. The Mummy (1932)
The original The Mummy is a landmark of horror cinema, starring Boris Karloff as the resurrected priest Imhotep. Unlike the rampaging monster of later versions, Karloff's mummy is a tragic, intelligent figure who uses manipulation and magic to pursue his lost love. The film is more atmospheric and psychological than its successors, relying on slow-burn tension and eerie visuals. While it may feel dated to modern audiences, its influence on the genre is undeniable. It's a classic that deserves respect, even if it's not the most thrilling watch today.
1. The Mummy (1999)
Topping the list is the 1999 blockbuster starring Brendan Fraser and Rachel Weisz. This is the one that redefined the mummy for a new generation, blending action, adventure, and comedy with a healthy dose of horror. Fraser's charismatic hero, Weisz's plucky librarian, and the terrifying yet charismatic Imhotep (Arnold Vosloo) make for an unforgettable trio. The film is a rollercoaster ride of set pieces, from the plague of locusts to the thrilling climax. It's not a masterpiece, but it's endlessly entertaining and has aged remarkably well. For sheer fun, nothing beats this version.
So there you have it: the four movies called The Mummy, ranked. Whether you prefer the classic horror of the 1932 original or the blockbuster thrills of the 1999 hit, there's a mummy for every taste. Just avoid the 2017 one—unless you're a fan of cinematic trainwrecks.
