Just six episodes into its tenth season, 9-1-1 has already delivered its midseason finale, and the shift in focus is hard to miss. For years, the show's emotional core was Athena (Angela Bassett) and Bobby (Peter Krause), but with Bobby's death, Athena now leads the ensemble. Yet, this season has quietly handed the spotlight to Buck (Oliver Stark), and the imbalance is becoming a glaring issue.
Buck's arc this season has been a frustrating loop. He impulsively gives up fostering Theo (Lincoln and Theodore Sykes), a decision that feels more like regression than growth. Five of the season's six episodes have revolved around this storyline, and every interaction between Buck and Eddie (Ryan Guzman) has been about Theo. While that could have been a rich vein to mine, the show keeps spinning its wheels, giving Buck plenty of screen time but little actual development. Meanwhile, Eddie is pushed to the sidelines, reduced to a supporting player in Buck's drama.
Eddie's Big Moment Gets Overshadowed
Last week's episode finally gave Eddie a chance to step into the spotlight when he chose to foster Theo himself. It was a bold, selfless move—one that put Theo's needs above his complicated feelings for Buck. The setup was ripe for exploration: How would Eddie handle raising a second child? What memories of Christopher's (Gavin McHugh) childhood would surface? And how would he process Buck's hurtful words? This was a golden opportunity to dive into Eddie's psyche, a rare treat for a character who's often been underutilized.
Instead, the midseason finale barely scratches the surface. The long-awaited first scene between Eddie and Maddie (Jennifer Love Hewitt) arrives, but it's a letdown. Maddie, who's never shied away from calling out Buck's bad behavior, here takes his side, accusing Eddie of fostering Theo just to teach Buck a lesson. It's a baffling choice, especially since Eddie isn't acting against Buck at all. The entire 118, save for Ravi (Anirudh Pisharody), backs Buck, and Eddie is left without a chance to voice his own feelings or explain his new role as a foster parent. Instead, he oddly emphasizes Buck's importance as Theo's biological parent, a line that feels out of character.
The Buck and Eddie Dynamic Is Suffering
What made Buck and Eddie's friendship so beloved was their unwavering support for each other. They've been through hell together, always showing up when it mattered. But this season, that dynamic has flipped. Eddie has offered Buck honest, helpful advice, only to be met with lashing out. He's gone out of his way to help Buck and Theo, and Buck has repaid him with anger. The promise they made to have each other's backs feels hollow now—Eddie is constantly watching Buck's, while Buck can't even be bothered to look back.
Everyone is coddling Buck this season, except Eddie, who's been remarkably gentle despite the mistreatment. He even refuses to accept Buck's half-hearted apology without blaming himself. It's a frustrating dynamic that undermines both characters.
What 9-1-1 Should Do Next
Eddie becoming a foster parent has the potential to be a fantastic storyline—but not if it's just a placeholder until Buck is ready to take Theo back. The show should lean into Eddie's journey: the challenges, the joys, and the echoes of Christopher's childhood. Then, either Theo stays with Eddie, or Buck and Eddie find a solution that respects both of them. Having Eddie simply hand Theo back would be a disservice to his character and to the audience.
For a show that's always excelled at balancing its ensemble, 9-1-1 is dropping the ball this season. Eddie deserves more than crumbs from Buck's table. It's time for the writers to give him a story of his own—one that doesn't revolve around his best friend's latest crisis. The midseason break is the perfect chance to recalibrate.
9-1-1 returns to ABC on Thursday, January 7 at 8:00 P.M. EST.
