Dark, twisted crime dramas have become a staple of modern television, with shows like True Detective setting an incredibly high bar. Every streamer seems to be chasing that same gritty, atmospheric magic, but few succeed. Enter Nocturne, Apple TV's latest foray into the genre, which brings together an impressive ensemble and a chilling premise. Based on Lars Kepler's novel The Sandman, this series has all the ingredients for a standout thriller—but does it deliver?
A Promising Premise with a Fresh Setting
Nocturne relocates the story from Stockholm to rural Western Pennsylvania, where former detective Jonah Lynn (Liev Schreiber) is still haunted by the capture of serial killer Jurek Walter (Stephen Graham) and the tragic loss of his own family. When a boy who vanished years ago suddenly reappears, the quiet town of Fairhaven is thrown into chaos. The hope that other missing persons might still be alive clashes with the fear that Walter, locked away in a psychiatric facility, may not have acted alone.
The series wastes no time in establishing its central mystery. FBI agent Saga Bauer (Zazie Beetz) goes undercover at Walter's facility, hoping to extract information from the manipulative killer. As the investigation unfolds, secrets buried for years begin to surface, keeping viewers on edge. The pacing is tight across the seven episodes screened, with each installment peeling back new layers. It's a mystery box that hooks you, even when the writing occasionally stumbles.
Overproduction Undermines Authenticity
Where Nocturne struggles is in its visual and tonal execution. The series is undeniably polished—perhaps too polished. Every shot is bathed in a sleek sheen, with heavy use of stylized lighting and camera tricks that feel at odds with the grounded, small-town setting. Compare this to the raw, documentary-like feel of True Detective, and you'll see why Nocturne sometimes feels less authentic than it should. The dialogue, too, often sounds like it's trying too hard to be quotable, sacrificing naturalism for dramatic effect.
This overproduction is a double-edged sword. On one hand, it makes the show visually striking; on the other, it creates a disconnect between the audience and the characters. You're always aware you're watching a TV show, not being immersed in a world. It's a shame, because the story itself is strong enough to carry the series without all the extra polish.
A Cast That Elevates the Material
Fortunately, the ensemble is more than capable of rising above the script's shortcomings. Liev Schreiber delivers a reliably solid performance as the tormented Jonah, but it's Bill Camp who truly steals the show. As the town's sheriff, Camp brings a grounded, lived-in quality that anchors the series. His flawless Western Pennsylvania accent and understated charm make every scene he's in feel more real. Zazie Beetz and Stephen Graham also shine, though they take a few episodes to fully settle into their roles.
As the season progresses, the cast's chemistry improves, and the writing tightens. By the time the credits roll on the final episode, you'll be invested in these characters and their fates. It's a testament to the actors' talent that they can make even the weaker dialogue feel compelling.
Final Verdict
Nocturne is a solid addition to the crime thriller genre, offering a gripping mystery and strong performances. It may not reach the heights of its inspirations, but it's a worthy watch for fans of the genre. If you're looking for something to tide you over until the next True Detective-style hit, this is it. For more recommendations, check out our list of the best psychological thrillers of the 2020s or explore why Ray Donovan remains a standout crime drama. And if you're craving more Apple TV+ content, Severance is surging in popularity as its third season approaches.
