Netflix's The Body has taken the streaming world by storm, landing at #1 just a week after its release. Set in 2004, the series follows the Lions, a high school dance team in a devoutly religious small town. When new member Grace Franklin (Sofia Wylie) is left comatose after a hazing ritual, the team spirals into a web of cover-ups, paranoia, and questions about supernatural forces. If you've already devoured all eight episodes and are craving more, these seven shows deliver the same blend of mystery, teen angst, and eerie suspense.
School Spirits (2023–Present)
For a supernatural twist on the missing-person trope, School Spirits follows Maddie (Peyton List), a teen who vanishes from her high school. Her spirit remains trapped there, alongside ghosts of past students, with no memory of her final moments. With help from her best friend Simon (Kristian Ventura)—the only living person who can see her—Maddie investigates her own death. Like The Body, this series blends coming-of-age drama with psychological thriller elements, exploring the weight of secrets and the haunting consequences in a tight-knit community.
The Society (2019)
When a group of high schoolers returns from a canceled trip to find their entire town deserted, they must build a new society from scratch. The Society dives into the power struggles and moral dilemmas that arise when teens are left to govern themselves. It's a gripping look at how fear and ambition can tear a community apart—much like the Lions' desperate attempts to control their own narrative. If you enjoy seeing young characters forced into impossible choices, this one's for you.
The Midnight Club (2022)
Based on Christopher Pike's novels, The Midnight Club centers on terminally ill teens at a hospice who share scary stories—and secretly hope to cheat death. Ilonka (Iman Benson) arrives believing she can be cured by supernatural means, and her desperation spreads to the others. The show masterfully blurs the line between reality and imagination, much like The Body, where the girls question whether something otherworldly is at play. It's a haunting, emotional ride that will keep you guessing.
The OA (2016–2019)
If you're drawn to the spiritual and philosophical undertones of The Body, The OA is a must-watch. Prairie (Brit Marling) returns after a seven-year disappearance, now able to see and calling herself the "Original Angel." She shares her impossible story with five strangers, leaving viewers to question what's real. The series is a mind-bending exploration of faith, trauma, and the power of belief—perfect for fans who love a good mystery wrapped in the supernatural.
Yellowjackets (2021–Present)
For a darker take on teen dynamics, Yellowjackets follows a girls' soccer team stranded in the wilderness after a plane crash. The show jumps between their harrowing survival in the 1990s and their present-day lives, where the secrets of that time still haunt them. It's a psychological thriller that examines the primal instincts of young women under pressure—echoing the Lions' descent into fear and paranoia. If you liked the intense group dynamics in The Body, this will be right up your alley.
Midnight Mass (2021)
Set in a remote island community, Midnight Mass explores faith, guilt, and the supernatural when a mysterious priest arrives and miracles begin to happen. As the town's devotion grows, so does the horror lurking beneath. The series shares The Body's interest in religious fervor and the consequences of blind belief. It's a slow-burn horror that will leave you questioning everything.
Dark (2017–2020)
For a more complex mystery, Dark is a German sci-fi thriller that weaves time travel, family secrets, and a missing child into a mind-bending narrative. The show's intricate plot and atmospheric tone will appeal to fans of The Body's layered storytelling. As the characters uncover the truth about their town's dark history, they realize that everything is connected—just like the Lions' tangled web of lies.
These shows offer the perfect mix of suspense, supernatural intrigue, and teen drama to fill the void left by The Body. Whether you're in the mood for a psychological puzzle or a chilling horror story, there's something here to keep you binge-watching. And if you're looking for more recommendations, check out our list of Harlan Coben shows or dive into the greatest Emmy-winning miniseries for more top-tier viewing.
