Amy Poehler is back in the TV spotlight with Dig, a new Peacock series that marks her first leading comedy role in over a decade. The show, created by Poehler, Mike Schur, and J.J. Philbin, and based on Kate Myers' novel Excavations, brings together the creative minds behind Parks and Recreation and adds the formidable Hugh Laurie to the mix. Set on an archaeological dig in Greece, the series initially tries to fit the workplace comedy mold, complete with academic rivalries and dig-site hierarchies. But as the season progresses, it sheds that skin to reveal a more engaging caper about friendship and buried secrets.
Poehler stars as Elise DeBellnick, a dedicated archaeologist who has spent her career as the loyal second-in-command to Dr. Neville Wycombe (Laurie), a charismatic but self-important British professor who keeps postponing his retirement. Elise dreams of leading her own excavation in Scotland, but she's stuck managing a team of students who find her by-the-book approach off-putting. The show's early episodes lean into the familiar Schur-style workplace dynamics, but the real strength lies in the ensemble, particularly the women around Elise.
Geraldine Viswanathan plays Dylan, a former dig favorite who mysteriously left years ago, while Antonia Thomas is Clare, the efficient lab manager who clashes with Elise. Their backstories are hinted at but never fully fleshed out, leaving some emotional beats feeling unearned. However, Fina Strazza shines as Patty, Wycombe's twitchy and endearingly odd assistant. Strazza brings a cartoonish sincerity to the role that feels refreshingly authentic, and her chemistry with Poehler is a highlight. Kayvan Novak also adds comic relief as Stavros, the smitten local mayor.
The plot kicks into gear with the discovery of a rare artifact nicknamed "Pretty Woman," which sets off a mystery that drives the second half of the season. The artifact itself looks suspiciously pristine, but the show's pivot to a caper format is where it truly finds its footing. As the women are forced to collaborate, the workplace comedy scaffolding falls away, revealing a story about camaraderie and self-discovery. Poehler has described Elise as seeing herself in the younger women, and that generational dynamic adds depth to the narrative.
While Dig takes a few episodes to hit its stride, it's a rewarding watch for fans of Poehler and Schur's brand of humor. The show's shift from sitcom to caper is a bold move that pays off, and Poehler delivers a performance that reminds us why she's one of TV's most beloved comedic actresses. If you're looking for a new comedy with heart and a touch of mystery, Dig is worth digging into. And if you're a fan of Poehler's previous work, you might also enjoy our list of the sitcoms that defined perfection.
The series also features cameos from familiar faces like Mo Collins, adding to the Parks and Rec reunion vibe. While the show's early episodes may not immediately grab you, the payoff is worth the patience. Dig is a testament to Poehler's range and the creative team's willingness to experiment with genre. For those who enjoy a good caper with a side of character growth, this is a must-watch. And if you're planning a Peacock binge, be sure to check out what's leaving the platform soon.
In the end, Dig is a show that finds its treasure not in ancient artifacts but in the connections its characters forge. It's a delightful surprise that proves Poehler still has the comedic chops to lead a series, and it's a welcome addition to the streaming landscape. So grab your trowel and give it a shot—you might just uncover something special.
