When Good Omens first landed on Prime Video, it quickly became a cult favorite, winning over fantasy fans with its offbeat humor, irreverent take on biblical mythology, and the electric pairing of David Tennant and Michael Sheen. After a four-year wait, Season 2 arrived in 2023 to more praise and new guest stars. But behind the scenes, the show's future was thrown into turmoil when creator Neil Gaiman faced multiple allegations of sexual assault and misconduct in 2024. Gaiman, who had been the showrunner and a key creative force, stepped away from the project, leaving Season 3 to be completed without him. The result is a single 90-minute finale—a far cry from the six-episode seasons fans had come to expect—and it struggles to deliver the satisfying conclusion the series deserved.
A Show Haunted by Its Creator's Absence
Gaiman's influence was always the backbone of Good Omens, from its witty dialogue to its playful exploration of good versus evil. With his departure, that distinctive voice is noticeably muted. The teleplay now credits Michael Marshall Smith and Peter Atkins as co-writers, but their attempts to replicate Gaiman's style don't quite hit the mark. The episode's first third meanders, introducing new characters and plot threads that feel half-formed, before rushing to tie everything up in a chaotic sprint to the finish. The tonal inconsistency is jarring, especially for viewers who have just rewatched the earlier seasons. It's a shame, because the series was one of Prime Video's most unique offerings—a gem that stood out even among other Gaiman adaptations like Sandman or American Gods. For more on Prime Video's standout originals, check out our list of Best Movies on Prime Video This Week.
Tennant and Sheen: The Saving Grace
If there's one reason to watch the Good Omens finale, it's the undeniable chemistry between Tennant and Sheen. Tennant's Crowley is a delight, shifting effortlessly from sardonic to vulnerable, while Sheen's Aziraphale remains the heart of the story. Their reunion doesn't happen until about a third of the way through, but once they're together, the episode finds its footing. The final moments are among the sweetest in the entire series, offering a neat—if overly tidy—resolution to their long-running romance. However, the new characters introduced don't fare as well. Sean Pertwee appears as Brian Cameron, a gangster who takes Crowley's beloved Bentley, but his role feels like a wasted opportunity. Mark Addy pops in as Harry the Fish, a hustler who befriends Jesus (played by Bilal Hasna), but their scenes, while charming, feel like filler in an already cramped runtime. For a show that once balanced its ensemble so well, these additions only highlight what's missing.
A Finale That Could Have Been Grander
Despite its flaws, the Good Omens finale is still enjoyable—thanks almost entirely to its leads. The episode manages to wrap up the central story in a way that will satisfy most fans of Aziraphale and Crowley's relationship. But it's hard not to feel disappointed. The series deserved a grander send-off, one that honored its quirky spirit and intricate plotting. Instead, we get a rushed, uneven episode that feels like a shadow of what came before. It's a bittersweet end to a show that was once one of Prime Video's most exciting properties. If you're looking for other Prime Video shows that deliver on their promise, don't miss Why Prime Video's 'The Boys' Final Season Is Must-Watch TV in May 2026.
