Alan Cumming has proven time and again that he's one of the most versatile performers in the entertainment industry. From his Tony-winning stage work to his beloved film roles in the Spy Kids trilogy, Romy and Michele's High School Reunion, and Spice World, he's captured the hearts of multiple generations. His transition to television brought him three Emmy nominations for his portrayal of the sharp-tongued lawyer Eli Gold on The Good Wife. But it's his current reign as the flamboyant host of The Traitors—a role that has earned him six Emmy wins—that has made him a household name once again. While his over-the-top, Shakespearean-style hosting, complete with a dazzling wardrobe, is undeniably entertaining, there's another gem in his filmography that deserves your attention: Schmigadoon!.
What Is 'Schmigadoon!' About?
Premiering on Apple TV+ in 2021, Schmigadoon! is a clever musical comedy created by Cinco Paul and Ken Daurio. The show is a loving parody of classic musicals, with its first season paying homage to the Golden Age of the 1940s and 1950s, including nods to Brigadoon, Oklahoma!, South Pacific, and Carousel. The story follows two New York doctors, Melissa (Cecily Strong) and Josh (Keegan-Michael Key), who embark on a backpacking trip to mend their relationship. They stumble upon the mystical town of Schmigadoon, a place seemingly stuck in a bygone era where residents break into elaborate song-and-dance numbers at the drop of a hat. To leave, they must find true love and break the town's spell. The second season, titled Schmicago and released in 2023, shifts focus to the edgier musicals of the 1960s and 1970s, parodying hits like Chicago, Cabaret, and Sweeney Todd.
Alan Cumming Steals the Show
What makes Schmigadoon! truly unique is its brilliant writing. It takes beloved musical tropes and turns them on their head with a wink and a nod, offering a fresh, irreverent take on familiar stories. The series shines brightest during its big-budget musical numbers, which are sprinkled throughout each episode. Songs like "Corn Puddin'" (which earned an Emmy for Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics), "You Can't Tame Me," and Kristin Chenoweth's showstopping "Tribulation" are catchy and memorable, making you want to sing along.
The cast is a who's who of talent, with Strong and Key providing grounded anchors, and supporting performances from Chenoweth, Fred Armisen, Dove Cameron, Aaron Tveit, Ariana DeBose, Jane Krakowski, and Martin Short. Yet, Cumming stands out as a true scene-stealer. In Season 1, he plays Aloysius Menlove, the closeted gay mayor of Schmigadoon, delivering the amusing "Somewhere Love Is Waiting for You." In Season 2, he transforms into Dooley Blight, a Sweeney Todd-esque character, and chews the scenery with darkly hilarious songs. His comedic timing is impeccable, and his baritone voice is a delight.
Why You Should Binge It Now
Despite critical acclaim, Schmigadoon! was unfortunately canceled after two seasons, failing to gain the mainstream traction it deserved. However, the show's magic has found new life in a stage musical adaptation that debuted on Broadway in April and won four Tony Awards this year. For fans of The Traitors, watching Cumming in Schmigadoon! offers a different side of his immense talent—one that's equally captivating. If you're looking for a weekend binge, this is a perfect pick, especially if you enjoy musicals and clever comedy. And if you're in the mood for more Apple TV+ gems, you might also check out Anya Taylor-Joy's 'The Gorge' or Silo's powerful storytelling. Schmigadoon! is available to stream on Apple TV+ in the U.S.
