For decades, fans have debated the merits of the original theatrical cuts of the Star Wars trilogy versus George Lucas's later Special Editions. The 1997 re-releases, which added CGI and deleted scenes, were initially well-received but have since become controversial. Now, with news that the original 1977 Star Wars is finally getting a wide release, it's time to rank the three films as they were originally shown—before Lucas's revisions.
3. Return of the Jedi (1983)
While Return of the Jedi is often considered the weakest of the original trilogy, that's like calling a dish at a five-star restaurant merely "good." The film boasts a bigger budget and delivers spectacular set pieces, but it's the emotional core that truly shines. Luke Skywalker's final confrontation with Darth Vader and Emperor Palpatine is a masterclass in storytelling, culminating in Vader's redemption—a moment that defines the entire saga. Mark Hamill's performance is at its peak, and the throne room scene remains one of cinema's greatest climaxes.
However, this is also the film most damaged by Lucas's later tinkering. The infamous musical number in Jabba's palace, the awkward Sarlacc beak, and the replacement of the beloved "Yub Nub" ending with a slicker version all detract from the original's charm. The worst change came with the Blu-ray release, adding a comical "Noooo!" to Vader's redemption, undermining the most crucial beat of the franchise. The theatrical cut, though imperfect, is a magnificent piece of blockbuster filmmaking.
2. The Empire Strikes Back (1980)
Often hailed as the best Star Wars film, The Empire Strikes Back is a darker, more mature chapter that expands the mythology. Directed by Irvin Kershner, it features the iconic reveal of Darth Vader as Luke's father, a twist that redefined the series. The film's pacing, character development, and visual effects—all practical—remain stunning. The battle on Hoth and the duel on Cloud City are unforgettable. While the Special Edition added some minor tweaks, the original cut's power remains intact, making it a near-perfect sequel.
1. Star Wars (1977)
The original Star Wars is not just a movie; it's a cultural phenomenon. Rejected by every studio before 20th Century Fox took a chance, it became the blueprint for the modern blockbuster. Lucas's homage to serials, Westerns, and Akira Kurosawa's The Hidden Fortress created a timeless adventure. The film's scrappy $11 million budget and innovative practical effects still hold up today. The pacing is flawless, and the characters—Luke, Leia, Han, and the droids—are iconic.
The Special Edition changes, like Greedo shooting first, are widely derided, but the original cut remains a masterpiece. For younger viewers who have only seen the altered versions, the theatrical release is a revelation. It's a reminder of the collaborative genius that made Star Wars a legend. As we await the re-release, this ranking honors the original cuts that started it all.
For more on the legacy of classic franchises, check out our ranking of Ryan Murphy's Monster seasons or our best Peanuts specials.
