Even in Middle-earth, not every actor follows directions. The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 had to rethink its plans after a four-legged performer proved to be more of a handful than anyone expected.
In an exclusive chat with Collider, co-showrunner Patrick McKay and director Charlotte Brändström revealed that a dog introduced this season was originally meant to be a recurring presence alongside Arondir (Ismael Cruz Córdova). The pup was supposed to provide comic relief, interact with Orcs, and even return later in the season. But as McKay put it, "that dog was an absolute nightmare."
The trouble started early. Brändström explained that while the dog looked perfect for the role, keeping him still long enough to film was nearly impossible. "He looked great. He looked how we wanted, but we managed to get him to eat the bone at some point. It was very hard to keep him still," she said. "It was very hard to keep him still long enough to say, 'Camera, start rolling.'"
McKay laughed as he described the unusable footage piling up: "There's a hard drive filled with, like, bum takes and the dog whimpering and yelling and barking and going after the Orc. I mean, it was a nightmare." The result? "We ended up with less dog. However, I think that a little bit of dog goes a long way."
Despite the cutbacks, one scene survived that McKay particularly loves. In it, Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) returns from battle to find everyone else greeted by a partner or child—except Arondir, who has his dog. "I find it very touching, and I love Morfydd's performance," McKay said. That moment remains in the season, even if the dog's larger arc didn't.
The scaled-back canine storyline is part of a broader push to make Middle-earth feel more real in Season 3. The new episodes introduce Rivendell, the iconic Elven sanctuary from Peter Jackson's films. McKay explained their approach: "We really like building things. We really want these fantastical worlds to feel real and tangible and immersive. You know, one example I think of in the first episode is we introduce Rivendell, right? And I think the move that you and Alex came up with is starting in a virtual world and then entering into a physical set all in one shot."
Brändström emphasized the importance of giving actors something tangible to interact with, even if the final shot includes digital extensions. "For the actors, it's important to feel grounded. They need to touch stuff. They need to feel the world around them," she said. "They don't really care about whether we extend it then and add some mountains in the background, because they don't look at that. But they need to have something to be grounded, to touch, to feel. I mean, we even brought in horses on the stages and had a road that they could come up."
For fans curious about Arondir's fate, Córdova has teased a heartbreaking turn for the character. And if you're wondering why the Harfoots are missing this season, the showrunners explained that decision as a smart creative move. Meanwhile, Season 3 has already topped Prime Video's charts.
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 is now streaming on Prime Video. For more behind-the-scenes stories and updates on your favorite shows, stay tuned to Collider.
