The Sopranos is often labeled a crime drama, but that label barely scratches the surface. It's one of the funniest shows ever made, even without being a traditional comedy, and it excels as a family saga and a psychological exploration, thanks to Tony's therapy sessions. The show's fifth season is particularly strong, with a mix of brilliant episodes and a few that stumble. Here's our ranking of all 13 episodes from that season, from the merely good to the all-time greats.
13. "In Camelot" (Episode 7)
Steve Buscemi, who plays Tony's cousin Tony Blundetto, also directed this episode. While he helmed the iconic "Pine Barrens" in an earlier season, "In Camelot" doesn't reach those heights. The episode focuses on Tony confronting truths about his father after meeting one of his old mistresses, leading to one of the show's most uncomfortable scenes. Junior's subplot, where he tries to attend every funeral to escape house arrest, is darkly comic and more effective. The brief car chase between Tony and Phil is a highlight, but overall, this episode is a bit of a miss.
12. "Sentimental Education" (Episode 6)
This episode feels like a bit of a placeholder, exploring familiar territory. A.J. has school problems, and Tony B. is slowly being drawn back into a life of crime. It's not terrible, but it doesn't advance the season's plot much. The title references a film, but the episode itself is more of a filler, setting up the stronger episodes to come.
11. "Rat Pack" (Episode 2)
This episode focuses on informants, or "rats." Adriana is under pressure from the FBI, and Jack Massarone, who gives Tony a Rat Pack painting, ends up dead. It also introduces Tony B. and Phil Leotardo, who were released from prison in the season premiere. The episode is solid but not exceptional, setting up future conflicts.
10. "All Happy Families" (Episode 4)
Frankie Valli of The Four Seasons appears as Rusty Millio, a minor character. The episode also introduces David Strathairn as A.J.'s guidance counselor, with whom Carmela has a brief affair. It's a transitional episode that ties up loose ends from the season's early episodes, like the characters Lorraine and Jason, who are quickly forgotten. Feech is sent back to prison, and the episode moves the season forward.
9. "Unidentified Black Males" (Episode 9)
This episode continues the rocky road to reconciliation between Tony and Carmela. It's a realistic portrayal of their relationship, with setbacks and progress. The episode also touches on race and identity, as the title suggests. It's a strong episode that keeps the season's momentum going.
8. "Cold Stones" (Episode 11)
Carmela and Rosalie go to Paris, providing a change of scenery and a chance for Carmela to reflect on her life. Meanwhile, Tony B. goes on the run, and the episode builds tension. The Paris scenes are visually stunning and offer a contrast to the usual New Jersey setting. It's a well-crafted episode that balances character development with plot advancement.
7. "Marco Polo" (Episode 8)
This episode centers on Carmela's father's birthday party, bringing the family together. It's a quieter episode, focusing on family dynamics and Tony's relationship with his in-laws. The episode also shows Tony B. trying to go straight, but his past catches up with him. It's a character-driven episode that adds depth to the season.
6. "Two Tonys" (Episode 1)
The season premiere sets the stage, introducing Tony B. and Phil Leotardo, who are released from prison. The episode establishes the season's central conflict: Tony B.'s desire to go straight versus the pull of the mob. It's a strong opener that hooks viewers and sets up the season's themes.
5. "Irregular Around the Margins" (Episode 5)
This episode is a standout, focusing on Tony and Adriana's relationship, which takes a dangerous turn. The tension between Tony and Ralphie escalates, and the episode is filled with dark humor and suspense. It's a gripping hour that showcases the show's ability to blend drama and comedy.
4. "Where's Johnny?" (Episode 3)
This episode deals with Junior's mental decline, as he becomes increasingly confused. It's a poignant and sometimes heartbreaking look at aging and dementia. Meanwhile, Tony B. tries to find legitimate work, but his past makes it difficult. The episode is a powerful exploration of identity and loyalty.
3. "The Test Dream" (Episode 11)
This is one of the most surreal episodes of the series, featuring an extended dream sequence that delves into Tony's psyche. It's a bold and experimental episode that pays off, offering insight into Tony's fears and desires. The dream is filled with symbolism and references to earlier seasons, making it a must-watch for fans.
2. "Long Term Parking" (Episode 12)
This episode is a gut-wrenching turning point, with a devastating conclusion that changes the course of the season. It's a masterclass in tension and emotional impact, with performances that are both subtle and powerful. The episode is often cited as one of the best in the series, and for good reason.
1. "All Due Respect" (Episode 13)
The season finale is a tour de force, wrapping up the season's storylines with a mix of violence and introspection. It delivers on the promises of the season, with a shocking climax that leaves a lasting impression. It's a fitting end to a season that ranks among the show's best, and it sets the stage for the final season.
For more on the best of television, check out our list of crime shows with the most mind-blowing plot twists.
