Sometimes the best shows sneak up on you. Prime Video's latest drama, It's Not Like That, is doing exactly that—quietly becoming one of 2026's most talked-about surprises. With an impressive 100% score on Rotten Tomatoes from early reviews, this eight-episode series is winning over audiences without the usual fanfare.
Starring Scott Foley and Erinn Hayes, the show follows Malcolm, a pastor and widowed father of three, as he navigates single parenthood after losing his wife. His next-door neighbor Lori, played by Hayes, is his late wife's best friend and is herself dealing with a recent divorce. Together, they form an unexpected support system—and their bond starts to blur the lines between friendship and something more.
More Than Just a Faith-Based Drama
While marketed as a faith-based series, It's Not Like That subverts expectations. Critics have praised it for using faith as a moral compass rather than a heavy-handed message. As Variety noted, it's "a breath of fresh air without feeling like religious propaganda." The show focuses on universal themes: grief, love, parenting, and the messy reality of moving forward.
The series also dives deep into the lives of the kids. Malcolm's eldest daughter Flora struggles with her faith after her mother's death, while his son Justin faces bullying at school. Lori's children, Merritt and Casey, grapple with the fallout of their parents' divorce. Each storyline highlights how loss and change affect family members differently—and how they can lean on each other for comfort.
A Hidden Gem Worth Binge-Watching
Foley's performance has been singled out as a standout. Decider called him the perfect actor to humanize Malcolm, bringing empathy, humor, and charm to the role. The chemistry between Foley and Hayes is electric, making the will-they-won't-they tension all the more compelling.
If you're looking for a heartfelt drama that doesn't shy away from emotional depth, It's Not Like That is a must-watch. It's the kind of show that reminds you why family stories resonate so deeply—and why Prime Video continues to deliver some of the best hidden gems on streaming. For more underrated picks, check out our list of Prime Video Gems You'll Regret Not Binge-Watching Sooner.
From the creators of Parenthood, this series is a welcome addition to the landscape of American drama. It proves that even in a crowded streaming market, a quiet, well-crafted story can still make a big impact. Don't sleep on this one—it's destined to become a favorite.
