Warner Bros. has quietly scaled back Practical Magic 2's theatrical presence, pulling the fantasy sequel from over 2,900 screens just days before its digital debut. The movie, which opened in more than 4,000 theaters about a month ago, has now shrunk to roughly 1,200 locations—a clear sign that its big-screen run is winding down.
The legacy sequel, directed by Susanne Bier, has grossed just over $100 million worldwide, barely surpassing its predecessor's $95 million haul from 1998. Both films carried similar budgets, around $75 million, and both have earned lukewarm reviews. Practical Magic 2 currently sits at a 36% critics' score on Rotten Tomatoes, with the consensus noting that while Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman's sisterly chemistry shines, the plot feels mechanical and uninspired.
Despite the tepid critical reception, the movie has found a warmer audience, earning a 91% "Verified Hot" score on Rotten Tomatoes. That bodes well for its home entertainment prospects, especially since the original Practical Magic became a cult favorite after its video release. The sequel is arriving on digital just in time for spooky season, which could give it a boost among viewers looking for witchy entertainment.
Bullock and Kidman reprise their roles as the Owens sisters, with newcomers Maisie Williams and Joey King joining the cast. Bullock, who hasn't led a major theatrical release since The Lost City in 2022, has proven her box-office draw time and again, though this sequel hasn't matched her usual heights. Kidman, meanwhile, has become a streaming staple with hits like The Perfect Couple, also directed by Bier.
The film's digital release is set for October 13, alongside Alan Ritchson's Runner and the South Korean sci-fi film Hope. For fans of the original, this home viewing opportunity might be the perfect way to revisit the Owens family's magical world. If you're in the mood for more fantasy, check out our list of the best fantasy movies since 2010 or dive into Netflix fantasy gems that never had a bad season.
As Practical Magic 2 transitions to home screens, it joins a growing trend of theatrical releases finding their audience on streaming. The sequel's performance mirrors the original's trajectory, suggesting that its legacy may be cemented through home viewing rather than box office numbers. Stay tuned for more updates on this and other fantasy releases.
