Horror fans have been spoiled for choice lately, with theatrical hits like Obsession and Backrooms dominating conversations, and Scary Movie reviving a beloved franchise at the box office. But the streaming world is also delivering thrills, and one 2025 horror title is proving that a film's true audience can emerge long after its initial release.
Osgood Perkins, the director behind Longlegs and The Monkey, has quickly become one of the most distinctive voices in modern horror. His latest film, Keeper, a folk horror thriller, earned praise from genre legends like Guillermo del Toro, who called it "horror origami that skillfully folds into itself," and James Wan, who described it as "a terrifying, ghostly descent into madness." Despite these endorsements, the film struggled in theaters, landing a 50% critics' score and a 40% audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with a worldwide box office of just $6.2 million.
Now, Keeper is finding its stride on streaming. According to FlixPatrol, it is currently the #2 most popular movie on Hulu in the U.S., and its reach extends internationally. The film has cracked the Amazon Prime Video Top 10 in Brazil, Panama, and Uruguay, and it entered the HBO Max Top 10 in several Nordic countries, including Denmark, Finland, and Sweden. This streaming surge suggests that Keeper is finally connecting with the audience that missed it in theaters.
The film stars Tatiana Maslany as Liz, a free-spirited artist, and Rossif Sutherland as her boyfriend Malcolm, who retreat to a secluded woodland cabin for their one-year anniversary. What begins as an intimate getaway slowly unravels into a nightmare as two-hundred-year-old secrets surface. Perkins crafts a slow-burn atmosphere reminiscent of his earlier works like The Blackcoat's Daughter and Longlegs, blending dreamlike dread with occult twists. For many viewers, however, the pacing felt too deliberate and the tone too cold, leading to the mixed reviews.
Streaming platforms have a way of rewriting a film's legacy, especially for horror titles that find their niche audience over time. Keeper is a prime example of how a divisive release can gain traction when viewers discover it on their own terms. For those who have already binged the latest theatrical offerings, this is a must-watch that rewards patience.
If you're looking for more underrated thrillers, check out Ana de Armas' Underrated Thriller 'The Informer' Finally Gets Its Streaming Due in June 2026. For fans of Stephen King's favorite horror series, 'Teacup' Is a Must-Binge Summer Thrill. And if you're into gripping crime thrillers, Justin Hartley Heads to ABC for Gritty Crime Thriller 'A Forgotten Kill'.
Keeper is now streaming on Hulu, and its success is a testament to the power of streaming to give overlooked films a second life. Whether you're a fan of Perkins' previous work or just love a slow-burn horror with occult layers, this one is worth your time.
