2026 has been a standout year for Nicole Kidman. After the mixed reception of Holland and her executive producer role on The Last Anniversary, she bounced back with two streaming hits: Scarpetta on Prime Video and the critically adored Margo's Got Money Troubles on Apple TV+. Now, with fans hungry for more, one of her most overlooked films is about to find a perfect free streaming home.
Secret in Their Eyes, the 2015 thriller directed by Billy Ray, stars Kidman alongside Julia Roberts and Chiwetel Ejiofor. The film is a remake of the Oscar-winning Argentine film of the same name, which itself was based on a novel by Eduardo Sacheri. It follows a team of investigators who reopen a cold case that has haunted them for over a decade.
Upon its release, Secret in Their Eyes earned a lukewarm 39% on Rotten Tomatoes, with critics calling it "not quite peculiar enough to be interesting" and "a mediocre adaptation." But time has been kind to this tense, emotionally charged drama. Many viewers now appreciate its layered performances and gripping narrative, even if it doesn't quite match the original's brilliance.
Starting June 1, 2026, you can stream Secret in Their Eyes for free on Plex. It's a great opportunity to catch a film that deserves a second look—especially if you're a fan of Kidman's recent work or Ejiofor's intense dramatic turns. For more on underrated thrillers, check out our list of 5 Forgotten '90s Thrillers That Hit Harder Today.
Why Now Is the Perfect Time to Watch
Kidman's recent success with Margo's Got Money Troubles and the upcoming Practical Magic 2 (hitting theaters September 11, 2026) has reignited interest in her filmography. Practical Magic 2 sees Kidman and Sandra Bullock reprising their roles as the Owens sisters, with Susanne Bier directing and a stellar new cast including Joey King, Maisie Williams, and Xolo Maridueña. Watching Secret in Their Eyes is a great way to get in the mood for that magical reunion.
For those who love a good crime thriller, Secret in Their Eyes offers a slow-burn mystery that explores guilt, obsession, and justice. Ejiofor delivers a powerhouse performance as a former FBI agent, while Roberts and Kidman bring depth to their roles as a detective and a district attorney, respectively. The film's emotional weight lingers long after the credits roll.
If you're looking for more gripping thrillers, don't miss our coverage of Bill Skarsgård's Gripping Crime Thriller 'Dead Man's Wire' Now Streaming on Netflix and Prime Video's 'Cross' Becomes the Must-Watch Crime Thriller Reacher Fans Need—Season 3 Update.
What to Expect from Secret in Their Eyes
The story centers on a team of investigators who are haunted by the unsolved murder of a young woman. Thirteen years later, a shocking discovery forces them to confront the case—and their own buried secrets. The film weaves together past and present, building to a devastating climax that will leave you breathless.
While it may not have been a critical darling, Secret in Their Eyes has found a loyal audience over the years. Its themes of justice and memory resonate more deeply now than ever. And with free streaming on Plex, there's no reason not to give it a chance.
Stay tuned to ShowtimeSpot for more streaming updates and exclusive entertainment news.
