Fresh off her Emmy-winning turn in Ozark and a standout role in Marvel's The Fantastic Four: First Steps, Julia Garner is diving into another gripping true-crime story. The actress has signed on to star in and executive produce Guilty Creatures, a new thriller series for Apple TV+ that adapts Mikita Brottman's acclaimed book Guilty Creatures: Sex, God, and Murder in Tallahassee, Florida.
The series, which has officially been ordered by Apple TV+, will be directed by Craig Gillespie (I, Tonya), with Stuart Zicherman serving as showrunner and executive producer. Sarah DeLappe (Bodies Bodies Bodies) is adapting the book for television. The project is produced by Tomorrow Studios, an ITV Studios partner, in collaboration with Garner's Alma Margo and Gillespie's Fortunate Jack Productions.
What Is 'Guilty Creatures' About?
While specific details about Garner's character remain under wraps, the series is based on a true story that unfolds in Florida's panhandle. The narrative centers on two young, devoutly religious lovers who embark on a passionate affair—and then commit murder. Their double life as killers spans 18 years, exploring the emotional toll of living with such a dark secret. The book delves into themes of sex, faith, and violence, offering a complex portrait of the couple and the community they deceived.
Brottman's book, published in 2021, was praised for its deep dive into the psychology of the perpetrators and the cultural backdrop of Tallahassee. The adaptation promises to bring that same nuance to the screen, blending true-crime intrigue with a character-driven thriller.
Garner's Busy Slate
Garner is no stranger to high-profile projects. After her breakout role as Ruth Langmore in Netflix's Ozark, she earned an Emmy and widespread acclaim. She later headlined the miniseries Inventing Anna and appeared in the 2025 films The Fantastic Four: First Steps and Weapons. Her upcoming schedule is packed: she'll star alongside Anthony Boyle in Netflix's limited series The Altruists, where she also executive produces, and is currently filming Tyrant opposite Charlize Theron for Amazon MGM Studios. She'll also appear in the next season of Apple TV+'s The Studio.
For fans of gripping crime dramas, Guilty Creatures joins a strong tradition of Apple TV+ thrillers. The streamer has built a reputation for high-quality, character-driven series, and this adaptation is poised to continue that trend. If you're looking for more crime content, check out our list of Apple TV+ shows that are absolutely perfect, no notes needed.
Behind the Scenes
The creative team behind Guilty Creatures is stacked. In addition to Gillespie and Zicherman, executive producers include Brottman herself, along with Marty Adelstein, Becky Clements, and Alissa Bachner from Tomorrow Studios. Annie Marter also executive produces through Fortunate Jack Productions. The series is one of several high-profile projects in development at Apple TV+, which continues to invest in premium adaptations.
As production moves forward, fans can expect more details about Garner's role and a release date. For now, the buzz around Guilty Creatures is building, and it's shaping up to be one of the most anticipated true-crime series in recent memory. Stay tuned to ShowtimeSpot for updates.
