The latest trip back to Panem has sparked a major divide between critics and moviegoers. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping hit theaters this weekend, and while professional reviewers have been less than enthusiastic, audiences are embracing the prequel with open arms.
Set 24 years before Katniss Everdeen ever volunteered as tribute, the film explores the 2nd Quarter Quell—a special edition of the deadly games that occurs every 25 years. This time, the Capitol doubles the number of tributes, forcing each district to send two boys and two girls into the arena. The story centers on a young Haymitch Abernathy, played by Joseph Zada, and his brutal path to victory.
Critics have given the movie a lukewarm 67% score on Rotten Tomatoes, a far cry from the franchise's best-reviewed entry, Catching Fire, which sits at 90%. But the audience verdict tells a different story: Sunrise on the Reaping currently boasts a 95% Verified Hot Audience Score, making it the highest-rated Hunger Games film among fans. On Letterboxd, it's also earning praise with a solid 4.1-star average.
Collider's Victoria Luxford awarded the film an 8/10 in her review, calling it a "dark and gritty" adaptation of Suzanne Collins' world. However, she noted that the runtime might test the patience of viewers who aren't deeply invested in the franchise's lore.
The strong audience response echoes the film's impressive box office performance. It claimed the fourth-biggest opening in the series, pulling in a massive $120 million debut that outpaced other new releases like The Odyssey. For more on that, check out our breakdown of its record-breaking weekend.
Director Francis Lawrence has also been teasing what's next for Panem, including a cut arena scene that didn't make the final film. Fans eager for more can read about the deleted sequence and the future of the franchise.
Looking at the entire Hunger Games saga, critics have historically favored the original trilogy, with Catching Fire leading the pack. The first film holds an 85% score, while the least-liked by critics is the previous prequel, The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, at 64%. Audiences, however, have flipped the script: Sunrise on the Reaping is now their top pick, followed by Catching Fire (89%) and the original (81%). The least popular with fans is Mockingjay – Part 2, which sits at just 66%.
This stark contrast between critical and audience reception isn't new, but it's particularly pronounced here. While some reviewers may find fault with pacing or narrative choices, the fans have spoken—and they're clearly hungry for more stories from this dystopian universe.
For those who've already seen the film and want to dive deeper, there are plenty of must-watch shows that capture a similar vibe. And if you're curious about how this installment ranks among the best in the series, our review of Haymitch's origin story offers a closer look.
