With Grand Theft Auto VI looming on the horizon as a potential 2026 Game of the Year contender, it's the perfect time to look back at the titles that have already claimed the crown. Since Geoff Keighley's Game Awards launched in 2014, the ceremony has become the premier stage for honoring the best in gaming. But which of these champions truly deserves the top spot? We've ranked every Game of the Year winner based on gameplay, narrative, art, design, originality, influence, and staying power.

12. Overwatch (2016)

Blizzard's hero shooter was a cultural phenomenon that defined the mid-2010s. Its vibrant cast of characters and team-based dynamics revolutionized multiplayer shooters, making it an obvious choice for GOTY in 2016. However, time hasn't been kind—the game feels stale now, and its sequel failed to recapture the magic. Still, at its peak, Overwatch was unstoppable.

Read also
Awards
10 Legendary Directors Who Never Got a Best Picture Oscar Nod
Some of cinema's greatest directors, like Hayao Miyazaki and John Woo, have never helmed a Best Picture Oscar nominee. Here are 10 legends who deserved the nod.

11. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (2025)

The most recent winner, this French indie gem blends real-time action with turn-based combat in a haunting world where a mysterious Paintress erases ages from existence. While its innovative gameplay loop, stellar voice acting, and gorgeous art direction earned it the 2025 prize, it faces stiff competition from a decade of heavy hitters.

10. The Last of Us Part II (2020)

Naughty Dog's sequel remains one of the most divisive GOTY winners. Its brutal narrative and controversial story choices split fans, but there's no denying its technical mastery. The stealth-action gameplay is top-notch, and the emotional journey—though harrowing—is a narrative masterclass. In a relatively weak year for gaming, it stood tall.

9. Astro Bot (2024)

Platformers rarely win GOTY, but Team ASOBI's delightful adventure broke the mold. After crash-landing, players explore vibrant worlds to rescue their crew, using haptic feedback and clever level design that teaches and challenges in equal measure. It's pure, joyful fun from start to finish.

8. Dragon Age: Inquisition (2014)

The very first Game Awards GOTY winner, BioWare's epic RPG set a new standard for the genre. With a massive world, compelling characters, and a lore-rich story about the Herald of Andraste leading the Inquisition, it remains a standout. Its party dynamics and cinematic combat defined the genre for years to come.

For more ranked lists, check out our take on the most exciting upcoming fantasy movies or the most flawless TV dramas of the past six years.