Perfection is a word thrown around a lot in gaming, but true perfection is rare. Even the most beloved titles have their quirks and imperfections. This list highlights fantasy games that are so close to flawless that their minor issues stand out all the more. From epic RPGs to indie gems, these games are nearly perfect, but not quite.
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
CD Projekt Red's magnum opus is often cited as one of the greatest RPGs ever made. The story of Geralt of Rivia searching for his adopted daughter Ciri across a war-torn continent is gripping, and the side quests are legendary for their depth and moral ambiguity. However, the combat can feel repetitive, and controlling Roach, your trusty steed, is often a frustrating experience. These small annoyances keep it from being truly flawless, but it remains a masterpiece.
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Bethesda's open-world epic is a cultural phenomenon. The freedom to explore, the rich lore, and the ability to become anyone you want are unparalleled. Yet, the game is notorious for its clunky combat and awkward movement, which have been a Bethesda staple for years. Despite these issues, Skyrim's immersive world and endless quests have kept players coming back for over a decade.
Final Fantasy XV
This entry in the long-running franchise is a road trip adventure that focuses on the bond between Prince Noctis and his three friends. The camaraderie is the game's strongest asset, making the journey feel personal. However, the narrative is disjointed, with key story moments happening off-screen or in DLC, and the transition from open-world to linear is jarring. It's a beautiful game with a lot of heart, but it's not without its flaws.
Jade Empire
BioWare's martial arts RPG is a hidden gem that deserves more recognition. Set in a world inspired by Chinese mythology, it offers a unique setting and a compelling story. The combat system is stylish, allowing players to switch between different fighting styles in real-time. However, the combat is also quite simplistic and can be easily exploited, which prevents it from reaching its full potential.
Elden Ring
FromSoftware's open-world masterpiece is a triumph of design and atmosphere. The sense of discovery and the challenge of its combat are unmatched. Yet, the story is told through cryptic lore and item descriptions, which isn't for everyone. Additionally, the late-game difficulty spike can feel unfair, even for seasoned players. These issues are minor compared to the game's achievements, but they keep it from being perfect.
Pillars of Eternity
Obsidian's classic CRPG is a love letter to the genre. Its worldbuilding is incredible, blending philosophy and magic in a way that feels fresh. However, the game is heavy on exposition, with walls of text that can be overwhelming and slow down the pacing. It's a fantastic game for those who love deep lore, but it's not for everyone.
Valheim
This Viking survival game took the gaming world by storm with its cooperative gameplay and beautiful procedural world. The sense of exploration and building is incredibly satisfying. However, the game is still in early access, and some mechanics feel unpolished. The combat is simple, and the boss fights can be repetitive. Despite these issues, Valheim offers a near-perfect survival experience that keeps players coming back.
These games are all exceptional in their own right, and their flaws are often what make them memorable. They may not be perfect, but they come close enough that we can't help but love them. For more fantasy recommendations, check out our list of fantasy films that nearly achieve perfection or dive into some fantasy novels that transport you.
