Billy Bob Thornton is enjoying a career resurgence thanks to his role in Taylor Sheridan's Landman, but a forgotten film from his past is quietly making waves on streaming. All the Pretty Horses, the 2000 Western starring Matt Damon and Penélope Cruz, has unexpectedly become a hit on Netflix in several international markets.
The film, based on Cormac McCarthy's acclaimed novel, was a passion project for Thornton, who directed and co-wrote the adaptation. However, its release was marred by behind-the-scenes turmoil, most notably when Miramax's Harvey Weinstein drastically cut the runtime against Thornton's wishes. The theatrical version ran about two hours, while Thornton's original cut was nearly three hours and forty minutes.
Critics were unkind, calling the film "flat" and "uninvolving," and it bombed at the box office, grossing just $18.1 million against a $57 million budget. For years, it was largely forgotten, a footnote in the careers of its stars. But now, Netflix has licensed the film for multiple territories, and it's charting in several countries, introducing a new generation to this ambitious Western.
Interestingly, the film is not available on Netflix in the US, where it can be streamed via premium video-on-demand services. This international success has reignited interest in the film, and fans are hoping it might lead to the release of Thornton's director's cut.
Matt Damon has long championed the longer version, calling it "the best thing I've ever been a part of." He argued that cutting 35% of the movie fundamentally changed it, and many of the criticisms about pacing and coherence could be traced to the studio's edits. Thornton himself has expressed a desire to release his cut, but complicated rights issues have so far prevented it.
In a 2022 interview, Thornton revealed he still has a copy of the director's cut and hopes to one day share it with audiences. As Landman continues to dominate the cultural conversation, this rediscovery of All the Pretty Horses serves as a reminder of Thornton's range as a filmmaker.
For those interested in exploring more of the genre, check out our list of the 2000s' finest Westerns. And for more on Thornton's current work, see the latest on Landman season 3.
While the film's troubled history is a cautionary tale about studio interference, its newfound popularity on streaming proves that great stories can find their audience eventually. Whether this will lead to a proper release of Thornton's original vision remains to be seen, but the buzz is certainly building.
