Antony Starr has become synonymous with the terrifyingly charismatic Homelander on The Boys, but long before he donned that red cape, he was delivering a performance just as compelling in a different kind of thriller. Banshee, the critically acclaimed crime series that originally aired from 2013 to 2016, is experiencing a massive resurgence on HBO Max in April 2026, proving that Starr's talent extends far beyond the world of superhero satire.
For fans who only know Starr as the psychotic leader of The Seven, Banshee offers a raw, visceral counterpoint. The show follows an ex-con who assumes the identity of a murdered sheriff in the small, corrupt town of Banshee, Pennsylvania. It's a role that allows Starr to showcase a different kind of intensity—one rooted in gritty realism and physicality rather than superhuman menace. The series, which also stars Ivana Milicevic and Ulrich Thomsen, holds a stellar 90% critic score and a 93% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, a testament to its enduring quality.
Why 'Banshee' Is Back in the Spotlight
The show's sudden return to the global streaming top 10, a full decade after its finale, is no accident. With The Boys gearing up for its final season on Prime Video, audiences are hungry for more Antony Starr. Banshee provides the perfect fix—a complete, four-season story that can be binged in a weekend. Unlike today's streaming landscape, where seasons can take years to produce, Banshee delivered all four of its seasons in just four years, a pace that feels almost nostalgic.
Created by David Schickler and Jonathan Tropper, the series is a masterclass in blending crime drama with psychological thriller elements. Tropper, who also penned the Apple TV+ series Your Friends and Neighbors starring Jon Hamm, brings a sharp, character-driven sensibility to the show. For those who appreciate tightly plotted thrillers, Banshee is a hidden gem that's finally getting its due. If you're a fan of shows like The Agency or Cross, this is a must-watch.
A Thriller That Refuses to Let Go
What sets Banshee apart is its unflinching approach to storytelling. The action is brutal, the characters are morally complex, and the plot twists keep you guessing until the very end. It's the kind of show that rewards patient viewers, building tension over multiple episodes before delivering explosive payoffs. For those who love psychological thrillers that refuse to let go, this series is a goldmine.
Starr's performance as Lucas Hood, the ex-con turned sheriff, is a revelation. He brings a quiet intensity and a sense of vulnerability that contrasts sharply with Homelander's unhinged arrogance. It's a reminder that Starr is not just a one-note actor but a versatile performer capable of anchoring a complex, multi-season arc. The supporting cast, including Tom Pelphrey in a breakout role, elevates the material even further.
Where to Watch and What's Next
All four seasons of Banshee are currently streaming on HBO Max, and with the show's newfound popularity, it's the perfect time to dive in. Whether you're a die-hard Boys fan or just a lover of top-tier crime thrillers, this series delivers on every level. As we await the final season of The Boys, Banshee stands as a testament to Starr's range and a reminder that sometimes the best performances come from the most unexpected places.
For those who can't get enough of high-stakes heists and intricate plots, check out our ranking of the most flawless heist thrillers in cinema. And if you're looking for more streaming gems, keep an eye on ShowtimeSpot for the latest updates on The Boys and other must-watch series.
