Ever since Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction first dared viewers to separate truth from tall tales, audiences have been hooked on the thrill of not knowing. Hosted by Jonathan Frakes, the show presented chilling, bizarre, and sometimes heartwarming stories, only revealing at the very end which ones actually happened. It was a masterclass in suspense, and it left a void that few series have managed to fill.

If you're still chasing that same rush—the one where you're second-guessing every detail and racing to solve the mystery before the credits roll—these six shows belong on your watchlist. They blend the supernatural, the strange, and the surprisingly true, all while keeping you on your toes.

Read also
TV Shows
Hidden Gems: 7 Netflix Miniseries That Are Flawless From Start to Finish
From Maniac to Unorthodox, these seven overlooked Netflix miniseries are flawless from start to finish. Don't miss these hidden gems.

1. The UnXplained (2019–Present)

William Shatner may be best known as Captain Kirk, but in The UnXplained, he trades the starship for a tour guide's chair, leading viewers through some of the world's most baffling real-life phenomena. From secret societies to alien encounters and inexplicable weather events, each episode dives into stories that defy easy explanation. The show pairs expert interviews with eyewitness accounts and archival footage, creating a compelling case for the unknown. For Beyond Belief fans, the Star Trek connection between Shatner and Frakes is a fun bonus, but the real draw is Shatner's commanding presence—he makes even the most outlandish tale feel eerily plausible.

2. Lore (2017–2018)

Based on Aaron Mahnke's award-winning podcast, Lore is a horror anthology that digs into the true stories behind myths and legends. Mahnke narrates the Prime Video series with the same eerie calm that made his podcast a hit, guiding viewers through tales of hauntings, curses, and folkloric horrors. What sets Lore apart is its commitment to showing how real events and cultural fears gave rise to the supernatural stories we tell today. Like Frakes, Mahnke has a knack for drawing you in and making you question what you thought you knew. Just be warned: this one isn't for the faint of heart.

3. Breaking the Magician's Code: Magic's Biggest Secrets Finally Revealed (2002–2009)

Magicians guard their secrets fiercely, but this controversial series blew the lid off some of the most iconic illusions ever performed. Hosted by Mitch Pileggi, Breaking the Magician's Code featured a masked magician who demonstrated how tricks are done—from levitation to vanishing acts. It's a bit like Beyond Belief in reverse: instead of asking you to guess what's real, it shows you exactly how the impossible is achieved. The reveal is often surprisingly simple, and that's part of the fun. If you love the moment of revelation, this one delivers it again and again.

4. Mysteries at the Museum (2010–2020)

Truth really is stranger than fiction, and Mysteries at the Museum proves it one artifact at a time. Host Don Wildman takes viewers inside museums around the world to examine peculiar objects—like vampire-hunting kits, shrunken heads, and unexplained relics—and the bizarre stories behind them. The show blends expert interviews, archival footage, and dramatic reenactments, much like Beyond Belief. Each episode is a reminder that history is full of oddities that defy logic, and Wildman's enthusiasm is infectious. It's a must-watch for anyone who loves a good puzzle.

5. Fact or Faked: Paranormal Files (2010–2012)

Instead of scripted stories, Fact or Faked: Paranormal Files puts real footage and photos under the microscope. A team of investigators—including a former FBI agent and a special effects expert—attempt to recreate viral videos of ghosts, cryptids, and UFOs to determine if they're genuine or hoaxes. The show doesn't rely on a single host; instead, the team members bring their own perspectives, creating a lively, sometimes chaotic dynamic. It's like Beyond Belief meets MythBusters, and it's just as addictive. If you've ever wondered whether that spooky viral clip is real, this is the show for you.

6. The X-Files (1993–2018)

No list of truth-seeking TV would be complete without The X-Files. Mulder and Scully's quest to uncover the truth about extraterrestrials, government conspiracies, and paranormal phenomena defined a generation. While it's a scripted drama, its DNA is deeply intertwined with the same questions that drive Beyond Belief: What is real? Who can you trust? And how far will you go to find out? The show's mix of standalone monster-of-the-week episodes and overarching mythology makes it endlessly rewatchable. For fans of Beyond Belief, it's the ultimate deep dive into the unknown.

Whether you're a skeptic or a believer, these shows will keep you guessing, questioning, and entertained. So dim the lights, grab some popcorn, and prepare to separate fact from fiction—one episode at a time.