Prime Video's Every Year After has quickly become a fan-favorite romance, weaving a friends-to-lovers-to-exes story that spans summers and secrets. But once you've finished all eight episodes, you might be craving more heartfelt love stories. Whether you're into love triangles, slow-burn connections, or emotional coming-of-age tales, these five shows will keep your heart fluttering.
1. Dawson's Creek (1998–2003)
No list of romantic dramas is complete without this iconic WB series. Set in the coastal town of Capeside, Massachusetts, Dawson's Creek follows four friends—aspiring filmmaker Dawson Leery, girl-next-door Joey Potter, slacker Pacey Witter, and troubled newcomer Jen Lindley—as they navigate first loves, heartbreaks, and adulthood. Creator Kevin Williamson gave these teens an articulate, emotionally complex voice that treated their struggles with real weight. The central love triangle between Dawson, Joey, and Pacey remains one of TV's most compelling, with natural, earned romantic arcs. If you loved the emotional depth of Every Year After, this classic is a must-watch.
2. My Life with the Walter Boys (2023–Present)
Netflix's adaptation of Ali Novak's novel follows Jackie Howard, a Manhattan teen who moves to a Colorado ranch after losing her parents. There, she's caught between two very different brothers: brooding bad boy Cole and kind-hearted Alex. The fish-out-of-water story blends fluffy teen drama with themes of grief, healing, and resilience. With a large ensemble cast, there's a character for everyone to root for. It's the perfect next step after Every Year After, especially if you love love triangles and small-town settings.
3. Normal People (2020)
Based on Sally Rooney's novel, this Hulu series captures the intense, on-again-off-again relationship between Marianne and Connell, from their high school years in Ireland through university. Daisy Edgar-Jones and Paul Mescal deliver raw, unforgettable performances that explore first love, miscommunication, and vulnerability. The show's realistic portrayal of romance—with all its highs and lows—makes it a perfect follow-up for fans who appreciate emotional authenticity. For more underrated gems, check out our list of Forgotten HBO Gems That Were Flawless from Start to Finish.
4. Sweet Magnolias (2020–Present)
Set in the charming small town of Serenity, South Carolina, this Netflix series follows three lifelong friends—Maddie, Helen, and Dana Sue—as they navigate careers, family, and romance. With its warm, community-focused storytelling and multiple love stories, Sweet Magnolias offers the same comforting, feel-good vibe as Every Year After. It's a gentle, uplifting watch that reminds us of the power of friendship and second chances.
5. One Day (2024)
This Netflix adaptation of David Nicholls' novel follows Emma and Dexter over 20 years, checking in on them every July 15th. From their university graduation to midlife, their will-they-won't-they romance is both heartbreaking and hopeful. The series captures the bittersweet nature of love and timing, much like the flashback structure of Every Year After. It's a poignant, beautifully acted drama that will stay with you long after the credits roll.
Whether you're in the mood for a classic teen drama or a modern love story, these shows will fill the void left by Every Year After. For more Prime Video recommendations, don't miss our Weekend Binge: 3 Prime Video Shows You Can't Miss.
