Fantasy is a genre so vast that every year, hundreds of remarkable books slip through the cracks, never getting the attention they deserve. Over the last ten years, a treasure trove of hidden gems has emerged—some from established authors, others from self-published newcomers—each offering something unique and unforgettable. Here are ten of the best underrated fantasy books published since 2016 that deserve a spot on your shelf.
Vermis, Lost Dungeons and Forbidden Woods (2023)
This isn't your typical novel—it's a stunning art book by artist Plastiboo, designed to look like a retro video game guide for a game that doesn't exist. Drawing inspiration from tabletop RPGs and dark fantasy video games, it's packed with atmospheric lore, maps, bestiaries, and lo-fi pixel art. For fans of grimdark and weird fiction, this is a unique piece of fantasy literature that's as creative as it is beautiful.
Illborn (2021)
Daniel T. Jackson's debut epic fantasy follows four young adults in a medieval world where the church persecutes anyone with supernatural abilities. As they discover their powers, they must flee for their lives. This character-driven saga is a gripping, sensory-rich journey that spans over 700 pages, with sequels that are equally compelling. It's a must-read for fans of epic fantasy who crave deep worldbuilding and emotional complexity.
Master of Sorrows (2019)
Justin Call's debut is a YA high fantasy that flips the genre's tropes on their head. It follows Annev, a student at an academy training warrior-thieves to eradicate magic, who discovers he's the reincarnation of an evil god. Fast-paced and morally complex, this book is a thrilling read for both younger and older audiences, offering a fresh take on the chosen one narrative.
Dreams of the Dying (2020)
Nicolas Lietzau, known for the acclaimed Skyrim mod Enderal, self-published this dark fantasy novel that blends psychological depth with epic worldbuilding. It follows Jespar, an ex-mercenary hired to enter the nightmares of a comatose king to prevent a war. Inspired by games and personal struggles, this book is a mind-bending adventure that feels like a fantasy twist on Inception.
The Ember Blade (2018)
Chris Wooding's epic fantasy is a masterful blend of classic tropes and grimdark subversions. It follows a young man who joins a rebellion to steal a king's sword after his father's execution. With over 800 pages of riveting plotting and memorable characters, this is a comfort read that still feels fresh and original.
Pilgrim: A Medieval Horror (2023)
Mitchell Lüthi's self-published historical dark fantasy is a standalone gem. Set in the 14th century, it follows a devout pilgrim on a grueling journey to a sacred shrine, but the path is fraught with horror and supernatural terror. It's a chilling, atmospheric read that proves fantasy can be just as terrifying as it is magical.
More Hidden Gems Worth Your Time
Beyond these, there are countless other underrated fantasy books from the past decade. For those who love epic fantasy films, check out our list of the greatest epic fantasy films for more inspiration. If you're a fan of historical fantasy, our ranking of the best historical fantasy books is a great companion. And for those who enjoy dark fantasy, don't miss our picks for underrated dark fantasy movies.
These hidden gems are a testament to the creativity and diversity of modern fantasy. Whether you're looking for an epic saga, a psychological thriller, or a visual feast, there's something here for every fantasy fan. So, dive in and discover your next favorite read.
